Revert "Always send lowlevel_error response to client (#2731)" (#2809)

This reverts commit f8acac1.

In response to #2808

lib/puma/request.rb

@@ -46,7 +46,11 @@ def handle_request(client, lines, requests)
       env[HIJACK_P] = true
       env[HIJACK] = client
 
-      env[RACK_INPUT] = client.body
+      body = client.body
+
+      head = env[REQUEST_METHOD] == HEAD
+
+      env[RACK_INPUT] = body
       env[RACK_URL_SCHEME] ||= default_server_port(env) == PORT_443 ? HTTPS : HTTP
 
       if @early_hints
@@ -65,58 +69,36 @@ def handle_request(client, lines, requests)
       # A rack extension. If the app writes #call'ables to this
       # array, we will invoke them when the request is done.
       #
-      env[RACK_AFTER_REPLY] = []
+      after_reply = env[RACK_AFTER_REPLY] = []
 
       begin
-        status, headers, res_body = @thread_pool.with_force_shutdown do
-          @app.call(env)
-        end
-
-        return :async if client.hijacked
-
-        status = status.to_i
-
-        if status == -1
-          unless headers.empty? and res_body == []
-            raise "async response must have empty headers and body"
+        begin
+          status, headers, res_body = @thread_pool.with_force_shutdown do
+            @app.call(env)
           end
 
-          return :async
-        end
-      rescue ThreadPool::ForceShutdown => e
-        @events.unknown_error e, client, "Rack app"
-        @events.log "Detected force shutdown of a thread"
-
-        status, headers, res_body = lowlevel_error(e, env, 503)
-      rescue Exception => e
-        @events.unknown_error e, client, "Rack app"
+          return :async if client.hijacked
 
-        status, headers, res_body = lowlevel_error(e, env, 500)
-      end
+          status = status.to_i
 
-      write_response(status, headers, res_body, lines, requests, client)
-    end
+          if status == -1
+            unless headers.empty? and res_body == []
+              raise "async response must have empty headers and body"
+            end
 
-    # Does the actual response writing for Request#handle_request and Server#client_error
-    #
-    # @param status [Integer] the status returned by the Rack application
-    # @param headers [Hash] the headers returned by the Rack application
-    # @param res_body [Array] the body returned by the Rack application
-    # @param lines [Puma::IOBuffer] modified in place
-    # @param requests [Integer] number of inline requests handled
-    # @param client [Puma::Client]
-    # @return [Boolean,:async]
-    def write_response(status, headers, res_body, lines, requests, client)
-      env = client.env
-      io  = client.io
+            return :async
+          end
+        rescue ThreadPool::ForceShutdown => e
+          @events.unknown_error e, client, "Rack app"
+          @events.log "Detected force shutdown of a thread"
 
-      return false if closed_socket?(io)
-      lines.clear
+          status, headers, res_body = lowlevel_error(e, env, 503)
+        rescue Exception => e
+          @events.unknown_error e, client, "Rack app"
 
-      head = env[REQUEST_METHOD] == HEAD
-      after_reply = env[RACK_AFTER_REPLY] || []
+          status, headers, res_body = lowlevel_error(e, env, 500)
+        end
 
-      begin
         res_info = {}
         res_info[:content_length] = nil
         res_info[:no_body] = head
@@ -167,9 +149,9 @@ def write_response(status, headers, res_body, lines, requests, client)
           res_body.each do |part|
             next if part.bytesize.zero?
             if chunked
-                fast_write io, (part.bytesize.to_s(16) << line_ending)
-                fast_write io, part            # part may have different encoding
-                fast_write io, line_ending
+               fast_write io, (part.bytesize.to_s(16) << line_ending)
+               fast_write io, part            # part may have different encoding
+               fast_write io, line_ending
             else
               fast_write io, part
             end
@@ -187,7 +169,7 @@ def write_response(status, headers, res_body, lines, requests, client)
       ensure
         uncork_socket io
 
-        client.body.close if client.body
+        body.close
         client.tempfile.unlink if client.tempfile
         res_body.close if res_body.respond_to? :close
 

lib/puma/server.rb

@@ -476,7 +476,7 @@ def process_client(client, buffer)
         end
         true
       rescue StandardError => e
-        client_error(e, client, buffer, requests)
+        client_error(e, client)
         # The ensure tries to close +client+ down
         requests > 0
       ensure
@@ -504,36 +504,34 @@ def with_force_shutdown(client, &block)
     # :nocov:
 
     # Handle various error types thrown by Client I/O operations.
-    def client_error(e, client, buffer = ::Puma::IOBuffer.new, requests = 1)
+    def client_error(e, client)
       # Swallow, do not log
       return if [ConnectionError, EOFError].include?(e.class)
 
+      lowlevel_error(e, client.env)
       case e
       when MiniSSL::SSLError
         @events.ssl_error e, client.io
       when HttpParserError
-        status, headers, res_body = lowlevel_error(e, client.env, 400)
-        write_response(status, headers, res_body, buffer, requests, client)
+        client.write_error(400)
         @events.parse_error e, client
       else
-        status, headers, res_body = lowlevel_error(e, client.env)
-        write_response(status, headers, res_body, buffer, requests, client)
+        client.write_error(500)
         @events.unknown_error e, nil, "Read"
       end
     end
 
     # A fallback rack response if +@app+ raises as exception.
     #
-    def lowlevel_error(e, env, status = 500)
+    def lowlevel_error(e, env, status=500)
       if handler = @options[:lowlevel_error_handler]
         if handler.arity == 1
-          handler_status, headers, res_body = handler.call(e)
+          return handler.call(e)
         elsif handler.arity == 2
-          handler_status, headers, res_body = handler.call(e, env)
+          return handler.call(e, env)
         else
-          handler_status, headers, res_body = handler.call(e, env, status)
+          return handler.call(e, env, status)
         end
-        return [handler_status || status, headers || {}, res_body || []]
       end
 
       if @leak_stack_on_error

test/test_puma_server.rb

@@ -363,17 +363,6 @@ def test_lowlevel_error_message
     assert (data.size > 0), "Expected response message to be not empty"
   end
 
-  def test_lowlevel_error_handler_custom_response
-    options = { lowlevel_error_handler: ->(_err) { [500, {}, ["error page"]] } }
-    # setting the headers argument to nil will trigger exception inside Puma
-    broken_app = ->(_env) { [200, nil, []] }
-    server_run(**options, &broken_app)
-
-    data = send_http_and_read "GET / HTTP/1.0\r\n\r\n"
-
-    assert_match %r{HTTP/1.0 500 Internal Server Error\r\nContent-Length: 10\r\n\r\nerror page}, data
-  end
-
   def test_force_shutdown_error_default
     server_run(force_shutdown_after: 2) do
       @server.stop

test/test_response_header.rb

@@ -45,15 +45,15 @@ def test_integer_key
     server_run app: ->(env) { [200, { 1 => 'Boo'}, []] }
     data = send_http_and_read "GET / HTTP/1.0\r\n\r\n"
 
-    assert_match(/HTTP\/1.0 500 Internal Server Error/, data)
+    assert_match(/HTTP\/1.1 500 Internal Server Error/, data)
   end
 
   # The header must respond to each
   def test_nil_header
     server_run app: ->(env) { [200, nil, []] }
     data = send_http_and_read "GET / HTTP/1.0\r\n\r\n"
 
-    assert_match(/HTTP\/1.0 500 Internal Server Error/, data)
+    assert_match(/HTTP\/1.1 500 Internal Server Error/, data)
   end
 
   # The values of the header must be Strings