New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Implement analyzer/fixer: remove unnecessary Call
keyword from Call
statement
#73233
Conversation
Call
statement
Call
statementCall
keyword from Call
statement
4526d0a
to
78de9a8
Compare
Not sure if we would take this for Roslyn itself. Seems like a good candidate for a community driven set of vb migration helpers though! |
That doesn't look like good news. |
ByVal isn't supported either
@tats-u I'm simply saying these might be better as a package you maintain yourself. |
@CyrusNajmabadi I wouldn't work on this PR anymore if you(r team) had no plan to make such kind of Analyzer/Codefix (Lighten the colors of unnecessary Call keywords) in the original Roslyn, VS, and online rich editors (and possibly VS Code in the future). |
e99a051
to
a4453d3
Compare
Lots of people maintain nuget packages. :-) But roslyn isn't a place where every but if functionality goes. This has a coat for us as well. So the benefit needs to be there to justify it. Given 30+ years working with vb, and only a single person asking for this, it really sounds like this is a feature for you, Rather than something significant for the entire community. If you're this passionate about producing solutions for your problems, that's great. But that doesn't really translate to us prioritizing it the same way. |
Note most VB users won't visit this repo (or vblang repo), and has given up for this feature or raising up their voice for new ones, not only new language ones (announced since .NET 5) but also other ones. Since your team chose to reject this feature and other new VB-dedicated just-nice-to-have ones even in Analyzer, I'll stop improving this code and focus on C# and other repos. I'll treat VB for .NET as like the IE mode and the Trident engine for Edge. |
Sounds good. Take it easy :) |
Fixes #71818
Mandatory:
Backlog: