client.go

/*
 *
 * Copyright 2019 gRPC authors.
 *
 * Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
 * you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
 * You may obtain a copy of the License at
 *
 *     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
 *
 * Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
 * distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
 * WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
 * See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
 * limitations under the License.
 *
 */

// Package xdsclient implements a full fledged gRPC client for the xDS API used
// by the xds resolver and balancer implementations.
package xdsclient

import (
	"context"
	"errors"
	"fmt"
	"regexp"
	"sync"
	"time"

	v2corepb "github.com/envoyproxy/go-control-plane/envoy/api/v2/core"
	v3corepb "github.com/envoyproxy/go-control-plane/envoy/config/core/v3"
	"github.com/golang/protobuf/proto"
	"google.golang.org/protobuf/types/known/anypb"

	"google.golang.org/grpc/internal/xds/matcher"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/xds/internal/httpfilter"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/xds/internal/xdsclient/load"

	"google.golang.org/grpc"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/internal/backoff"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/internal/buffer"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/internal/grpclog"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/internal/grpcsync"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/keepalive"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/xds/internal"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/xds/internal/version"
	"google.golang.org/grpc/xds/internal/xdsclient/bootstrap"
)

var (
	m = make(map[version.TransportAPI]APIClientBuilder)
)

// RegisterAPIClientBuilder registers a client builder for xDS transport protocol
// version specified by b.Version().
//
// NOTE: this function must only be called during initialization time (i.e. in
// an init() function), and is not thread-safe. If multiple builders are
// registered for the same version, the one registered last will take effect.
func RegisterAPIClientBuilder(b APIClientBuilder) {
	m[b.Version()] = b
}

// getAPIClientBuilder returns the client builder registered for the provided
// xDS transport API version.
func getAPIClientBuilder(version version.TransportAPI) APIClientBuilder {
	if b, ok := m[version]; ok {
		return b
	}
	return nil
}

// BuildOptions contains options to be passed to client builders.
type BuildOptions struct {
	// Parent is a top-level xDS client which has the intelligence to take
	// appropriate action based on xDS responses received from the management
	// server.
	Parent UpdateHandler
	// NodeProto contains the Node proto to be used in xDS requests. The actual
	// type depends on the transport protocol version used.
	NodeProto proto.Message
	// Backoff returns the amount of time to backoff before retrying broken
	// streams.
	Backoff func(int) time.Duration
	// Logger provides enhanced logging capabilities.
	Logger *grpclog.PrefixLogger
}

// APIClientBuilder creates an xDS client for a specific xDS transport protocol
// version.
type APIClientBuilder interface {
	// Build builds a transport protocol specific implementation of the xDS
	// client based on the provided clientConn to the management server and the
	// provided options.
	Build(*grpc.ClientConn, BuildOptions) (APIClient, error)
	// Version returns the xDS transport protocol version used by clients build
	// using this builder.
	Version() version.TransportAPI
}

// APIClient represents the functionality provided by transport protocol
// version specific implementations of the xDS client.
//
// TODO: unexport this interface and all the methods after the PR to make
// xdsClient sharable by clients. AddWatch and RemoveWatch are exported for
// v2/v3 to override because they need to keep track of LDS name for RDS to use.
// After the share xdsClient change, that's no longer necessary. After that, we
// will still keep this interface for testing purposes.
type APIClient interface {
	// AddWatch adds a watch for an xDS resource given its type and name.
	AddWatch(ResourceType, string)

	// RemoveWatch cancels an already registered watch for an xDS resource
	// given its type and name.
	RemoveWatch(ResourceType, string)

	// reportLoad starts an LRS stream to periodically report load using the
	// provided ClientConn, which represent a connection to the management
	// server.
	reportLoad(ctx context.Context, cc *grpc.ClientConn, opts loadReportingOptions)

	// Close cleans up resources allocated by the API client.
	Close()
}

// loadReportingOptions contains configuration knobs for reporting load data.
type loadReportingOptions struct {
	loadStore *load.Store
}

// UpdateHandler receives and processes (by taking appropriate actions) xDS
// resource updates from an APIClient for a specific version.
type UpdateHandler interface {
	// NewListeners handles updates to xDS listener resources.
	NewListeners(map[string]ListenerUpdate, UpdateMetadata)
	// NewRouteConfigs handles updates to xDS RouteConfiguration resources.
	NewRouteConfigs(map[string]RouteConfigUpdate, UpdateMetadata)
	// NewClusters handles updates to xDS Cluster resources.
	NewClusters(map[string]ClusterUpdate, UpdateMetadata)
	// NewEndpoints handles updates to xDS ClusterLoadAssignment (or tersely
	// referred to as Endpoints) resources.
	NewEndpoints(map[string]EndpointsUpdate, UpdateMetadata)
}

// ServiceStatus is the status of the update.
type ServiceStatus int

const (
	// ServiceStatusUnknown is the default state, before a watch is started for
	// the resource.
	ServiceStatusUnknown ServiceStatus = iota
	// ServiceStatusRequested is when the watch is started, but before and
	// response is received.
	ServiceStatusRequested
	// ServiceStatusNotExist is when the resource doesn't exist in
	// state-of-the-world responses (e.g. LDS and CDS), which means the resource
	// is removed by the management server.
	ServiceStatusNotExist // Resource is removed in the server, in LDS/CDS.
	// ServiceStatusACKed is when the resource is ACKed.
	ServiceStatusACKed
	// ServiceStatusNACKed is when the resource is NACKed.
	ServiceStatusNACKed
)

// UpdateErrorMetadata is part of UpdateMetadata. It contains the error state
// when a response is NACKed.
type UpdateErrorMetadata struct {
	// Version is the version of the NACKed response.
	Version string
	// Err contains why the response was NACKed.
	Err error
	// Timestamp is when the NACKed response was received.
	Timestamp time.Time
}

// UpdateMetadata contains the metadata for each update, including timestamp,
// raw message, and so on.
type UpdateMetadata struct {
	// Status is the status of this resource, e.g. ACKed, NACKed, or
	// Not_exist(removed).
	Status ServiceStatus
	// Version is the version of the xds response. Note that this is the version
	// of the resource in use (previous ACKed). If a response is NACKed, the
	// NACKed version is in ErrState.
	Version string
	// Timestamp is when the response is received.
	Timestamp time.Time
	// ErrState is set when the update is NACKed.
	ErrState *UpdateErrorMetadata
}

// ListenerUpdate contains information received in an LDS response, which is of
// interest to the registered LDS watcher.
type ListenerUpdate struct {
	// RouteConfigName is the route configuration name corresponding to the
	// target which is being watched through LDS.
	//
	// Only one of RouteConfigName and InlineRouteConfig is set.
	RouteConfigName string
	// InlineRouteConfig is the inline route configuration (RDS response)
	// returned inside LDS.
	//
	// Only one of RouteConfigName and InlineRouteConfig is set.
	InlineRouteConfig *RouteConfigUpdate

	// MaxStreamDuration contains the HTTP connection manager's
	// common_http_protocol_options.max_stream_duration field, or zero if
	// unset.
	MaxStreamDuration time.Duration
	// HTTPFilters is a list of HTTP filters (name, config) from the LDS
	// response.
	HTTPFilters []HTTPFilter
	// InboundListenerCfg contains inbound listener configuration.
	InboundListenerCfg *InboundListenerConfig

	// Raw is the resource from the xds response.
	Raw *anypb.Any
}

// HTTPFilter represents one HTTP filter from an LDS response's HTTP connection
// manager field.
type HTTPFilter struct {
	// Name is an arbitrary name of the filter.  Used for applying override
	// settings in virtual host / route / weighted cluster configuration (not
	// yet supported).
	Name string
	// Filter is the HTTP filter found in the registry for the config type.
	Filter httpfilter.Filter
	// Config contains the filter's configuration
	Config httpfilter.FilterConfig
}

// InboundListenerConfig contains information about the inbound listener, i.e
// the server-side listener.
type InboundListenerConfig struct {
	// Address is the local address on which the inbound listener is expected to
	// accept incoming connections.
	Address string
	// Port is the local port on which the inbound listener is expected to
	// accept incoming connections.
	Port string
	// FilterChains is the list of filter chains associated with this listener.
	FilterChains *FilterChainManager
}

// RouteConfigUpdate contains information received in an RDS response, which is
// of interest to the registered RDS watcher.
type RouteConfigUpdate struct {
	VirtualHosts []*VirtualHost

	// Raw is the resource from the xds response.
	Raw *anypb.Any
}

// VirtualHost contains the routes for a list of Domains.
//
// Note that the domains in this slice can be a wildcard, not an exact string.
// The consumer of this struct needs to find the best match for its hostname.
type VirtualHost struct {
	Domains []string
	// Routes contains a list of routes, each containing matchers and
	// corresponding action.
	Routes []*Route
	// HTTPFilterConfigOverride contains any HTTP filter config overrides for
	// the virtual host which may be present.  An individual filter's override
	// may be unused if the matching Route contains an override for that
	// filter.
	HTTPFilterConfigOverride map[string]httpfilter.FilterConfig
}

// HashPolicyType specifies the type of HashPolicy from a received RDS Response.
type HashPolicyType int

const (
	// HashPolicyTypeHeader specifies to hash a Header in the incoming request.
	HashPolicyTypeHeader HashPolicyType = iota
	// HashPolicyTypeChannelID specifies to hash a unique Identifier of the
	// Channel. In grpc-go, this will be done using the ClientConn pointer.
	HashPolicyTypeChannelID
)

// HashPolicy specifies the HashPolicy if the upstream cluster uses a hashing
// load balancer.
type HashPolicy struct {
	HashPolicyType HashPolicyType
	Terminal       bool
	// Fields used for type HEADER.
	HeaderName        string
	Regex             string
	RegexSubstitution string
}

// Route is both a specification of how to match a request as well as an
// indication of the action to take upon match.
type Route struct {
	Path   *string
	Prefix *string
	Regex  *regexp.Regexp
	// Indicates if prefix/path matching should be case insensitive. The default
	// is false (case sensitive).
	CaseInsensitive bool
	Headers         []*HeaderMatcher
	Fraction        *uint32

	HashPolicies []*HashPolicy

	// If the matchers above indicate a match, the below configuration is used.
	WeightedClusters map[string]WeightedCluster
	// If MaxStreamDuration is nil, it indicates neither of the route action's
	// max_stream_duration fields (grpc_timeout_header_max nor
	// max_stream_duration) were set.  In this case, the ListenerUpdate's
	// MaxStreamDuration field should be used.  If MaxStreamDuration is set to
	// an explicit zero duration, the application's deadline should be used.
	MaxStreamDuration *time.Duration
	// HTTPFilterConfigOverride contains any HTTP filter config overrides for
	// the route which may be present.  An individual filter's override may be
	// unused if the matching WeightedCluster contains an override for that
	// filter.
	HTTPFilterConfigOverride map[string]httpfilter.FilterConfig
}

// WeightedCluster contains settings for an xds RouteAction.WeightedCluster.
type WeightedCluster struct {
	// Weight is the relative weight of the cluster.  It will never be zero.
	Weight uint32
	// HTTPFilterConfigOverride contains any HTTP filter config overrides for
	// the weighted cluster which may be present.
	HTTPFilterConfigOverride map[string]httpfilter.FilterConfig
}

// HeaderMatcher represents header matchers.
type HeaderMatcher struct {
	Name         string
	InvertMatch  *bool
	ExactMatch   *string
	RegexMatch   *regexp.Regexp
	PrefixMatch  *string
	SuffixMatch  *string
	RangeMatch   *Int64Range
	PresentMatch *bool
}

// Int64Range is a range for header range match.
type Int64Range struct {
	Start int64
	End   int64
}

// SecurityConfig contains the security configuration received as part of the
// Cluster resource on the client-side, and as part of the Listener resource on
// the server-side.
type SecurityConfig struct {
	// RootInstanceName identifies the certProvider plugin to be used to fetch
	// root certificates. This instance name will be resolved to the plugin name
	// and its associated configuration from the certificate_providers field of
	// the bootstrap file.
	RootInstanceName string
	// RootCertName is the certificate name to be passed to the plugin (looked
	// up from the bootstrap file) while fetching root certificates.
	RootCertName string
	// IdentityInstanceName identifies the certProvider plugin to be used to
	// fetch identity certificates. This instance name will be resolved to the
	// plugin name and its associated configuration from the
	// certificate_providers field of the bootstrap file.
	IdentityInstanceName string
	// IdentityCertName is the certificate name to be passed to the plugin
	// (looked up from the bootstrap file) while fetching identity certificates.
	IdentityCertName string
	// SubjectAltNameMatchers is an optional list of match criteria for SANs
	// specified on the peer certificate. Used only on the client-side.
	//
	// Some intricacies:
	// - If this field is empty, then any peer certificate is accepted.
	// - If the peer certificate contains a wildcard DNS SAN, and an `exact`
	//   matcher is configured, a wildcard DNS match is performed instead of a
	//   regular string comparison.
	SubjectAltNameMatchers []matcher.StringMatcher
	// RequireClientCert indicates if the server handshake process expects the
	// client to present a certificate. Set to true when performing mTLS. Used
	// only on the server-side.
	RequireClientCert bool
}

// ClusterType is the type of cluster from a received CDS response.
type ClusterType int

const (
	// ClusterTypeEDS represents the EDS cluster type, which will delegate endpoint
	// discovery to the management server.
	ClusterTypeEDS ClusterType = iota
	// ClusterTypeLogicalDNS represents the Logical DNS cluster type, which essentially
	// maps to the gRPC behavior of using the DNS resolver with pick_first LB policy.
	ClusterTypeLogicalDNS
	// ClusterTypeAggregate represents the Aggregate Cluster type, which provides a
	// prioritized list of clusters to use. It is used for failover between clusters
	// with a different configuration.
	ClusterTypeAggregate
)

// ClusterUpdate contains information from a received CDS response, which is of
// interest to the registered CDS watcher.
type ClusterUpdate struct {
	ClusterType ClusterType
	// ClusterName is the clusterName being watched for through CDS.
	ClusterName string
	// EDSServiceName is an optional name for EDS. If it's not set, the balancer
	// should watch ClusterName for the EDS resources.
	EDSServiceName string
	// EnableLRS indicates whether or not load should be reported through LRS.
	EnableLRS bool
	// SecurityCfg contains security configuration sent by the control plane.
	SecurityCfg *SecurityConfig
	// MaxRequests for circuit breaking, if any (otherwise nil).
	MaxRequests *uint32
	// DNSHostName is used only for cluster type DNS. It's the DNS name to
	// resolve in "host:port" form
	DNSHostName string
	// PrioritizedClusterNames is used only for cluster type aggregate. It represents
	// a prioritized list of cluster names.
	PrioritizedClusterNames []string

	// Raw is the resource from the xds response.
	Raw *anypb.Any
}

// OverloadDropConfig contains the config to drop overloads.
type OverloadDropConfig struct {
	Category    string
	Numerator   uint32
	Denominator uint32
}

// EndpointHealthStatus represents the health status of an endpoint.
type EndpointHealthStatus int32

const (
	// EndpointHealthStatusUnknown represents HealthStatus UNKNOWN.
	EndpointHealthStatusUnknown EndpointHealthStatus = iota
	// EndpointHealthStatusHealthy represents HealthStatus HEALTHY.
	EndpointHealthStatusHealthy
	// EndpointHealthStatusUnhealthy represents HealthStatus UNHEALTHY.
	EndpointHealthStatusUnhealthy
	// EndpointHealthStatusDraining represents HealthStatus DRAINING.
	EndpointHealthStatusDraining
	// EndpointHealthStatusTimeout represents HealthStatus TIMEOUT.
	EndpointHealthStatusTimeout
	// EndpointHealthStatusDegraded represents HealthStatus DEGRADED.
	EndpointHealthStatusDegraded
)

// Endpoint contains information of an endpoint.
type Endpoint struct {
	Address      string
	HealthStatus EndpointHealthStatus
	Weight       uint32
}

// Locality contains information of a locality.
type Locality struct {
	Endpoints []Endpoint
	ID        internal.LocalityID
	Priority  uint32
	Weight    uint32
}

// EndpointsUpdate contains an EDS update.
type EndpointsUpdate struct {
	Drops      []OverloadDropConfig
	Localities []Locality

	// Raw is the resource from the xds response.
	Raw *anypb.Any
}

// Function to be overridden in tests.
var newAPIClient = func(apiVersion version.TransportAPI, cc *grpc.ClientConn, opts BuildOptions) (APIClient, error) {
	cb := getAPIClientBuilder(apiVersion)
	if cb == nil {
		return nil, fmt.Errorf("no client builder for xDS API version: %v", apiVersion)
	}
	return cb.Build(cc, opts)
}

// clientImpl is the real implementation of the xds client. The exported Client
// is a wrapper of this struct with a ref count.
//
// Implements UpdateHandler interface.
// TODO(easwars): Make a wrapper struct which implements this interface in the
// style of ccBalancerWrapper so that the Client type does not implement these
// exported methods.
type clientImpl struct {
	done               *grpcsync.Event
	config             *bootstrap.Config
	cc                 *grpc.ClientConn // Connection to the management server.
	apiClient          APIClient
	watchExpiryTimeout time.Duration

	logger *grpclog.PrefixLogger

	updateCh *buffer.Unbounded // chan *watcherInfoWithUpdate
	// All the following maps are to keep the updates/metadata in a cache.
	// TODO: move them to a separate struct/package, to cleanup the xds_client.
	// And CSDS handler can be implemented directly by the cache.
	mu          sync.Mutex
	ldsWatchers map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool
	ldsVersion  string // Only used in CSDS.
	ldsCache    map[string]ListenerUpdate
	ldsMD       map[string]UpdateMetadata
	rdsWatchers map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool
	rdsVersion  string // Only used in CSDS.
	rdsCache    map[string]RouteConfigUpdate
	rdsMD       map[string]UpdateMetadata
	cdsWatchers map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool
	cdsVersion  string // Only used in CSDS.
	cdsCache    map[string]ClusterUpdate
	cdsMD       map[string]UpdateMetadata
	edsWatchers map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool
	edsVersion  string // Only used in CSDS.
	edsCache    map[string]EndpointsUpdate
	edsMD       map[string]UpdateMetadata

	// Changes to map lrsClients and the lrsClient inside the map need to be
	// protected by lrsMu.
	lrsMu      sync.Mutex
	lrsClients map[string]*lrsClient
}

// newWithConfig returns a new xdsClient with the given config.
func newWithConfig(config *bootstrap.Config, watchExpiryTimeout time.Duration) (*clientImpl, error) {
	switch {
	case config.BalancerName == "":
		return nil, errors.New("xds: no xds_server name provided in options")
	case config.Creds == nil:
		return nil, errors.New("xds: no credentials provided in options")
	case config.NodeProto == nil:
		return nil, errors.New("xds: no node_proto provided in options")
	}

	switch config.TransportAPI {
	case version.TransportV2:
		if _, ok := config.NodeProto.(*v2corepb.Node); !ok {
			return nil, fmt.Errorf("xds: Node proto type (%T) does not match API version: %v", config.NodeProto, config.TransportAPI)
		}
	case version.TransportV3:
		if _, ok := config.NodeProto.(*v3corepb.Node); !ok {
			return nil, fmt.Errorf("xds: Node proto type (%T) does not match API version: %v", config.NodeProto, config.TransportAPI)
		}
	}

	dopts := []grpc.DialOption{
		config.Creds,
		grpc.WithKeepaliveParams(keepalive.ClientParameters{
			Time:    5 * time.Minute,
			Timeout: 20 * time.Second,
		}),
	}

	c := &clientImpl{
		done:               grpcsync.NewEvent(),
		config:             config,
		watchExpiryTimeout: watchExpiryTimeout,

		updateCh:    buffer.NewUnbounded(),
		ldsWatchers: make(map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool),
		ldsCache:    make(map[string]ListenerUpdate),
		ldsMD:       make(map[string]UpdateMetadata),
		rdsWatchers: make(map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool),
		rdsCache:    make(map[string]RouteConfigUpdate),
		rdsMD:       make(map[string]UpdateMetadata),
		cdsWatchers: make(map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool),
		cdsCache:    make(map[string]ClusterUpdate),
		cdsMD:       make(map[string]UpdateMetadata),
		edsWatchers: make(map[string]map[*watchInfo]bool),
		edsCache:    make(map[string]EndpointsUpdate),
		edsMD:       make(map[string]UpdateMetadata),
		lrsClients:  make(map[string]*lrsClient),
	}

	cc, err := grpc.Dial(config.BalancerName, dopts...)
	if err != nil {
		// An error from a non-blocking dial indicates something serious.
		return nil, fmt.Errorf("xds: failed to dial balancer {%s}: %v", config.BalancerName, err)
	}
	c.cc = cc
	c.logger = prefixLogger((c))
	c.logger.Infof("Created ClientConn to xDS management server: %s", config.BalancerName)

	apiClient, err := newAPIClient(config.TransportAPI, cc, BuildOptions{
		Parent:    c,
		NodeProto: config.NodeProto,
		Backoff:   backoff.DefaultExponential.Backoff,
		Logger:    c.logger,
	})
	if err != nil {
		return nil, err
	}
	c.apiClient = apiClient
	c.logger.Infof("Created")
	go c.run()
	return c, nil
}

// BootstrapConfig returns the configuration read from the bootstrap file.
// Callers must treat the return value as read-only.
func (c *Client) BootstrapConfig() *bootstrap.Config {
	return c.config
}

// run is a goroutine for all the callbacks.
//
// Callback can be called in watch(), if an item is found in cache. Without this
// goroutine, the callback will be called inline, which might cause a deadlock
// in user's code. Callbacks also cannot be simple `go callback()` because the
// order matters.
func (c *clientImpl) run() {
	for {
		select {
		case t := <-c.updateCh.Get():
			c.updateCh.Load()
			if c.done.HasFired() {
				return
			}
			c.callCallback(t.(*watcherInfoWithUpdate))
		case <-c.done.Done():
			return
		}
	}
}

// Close closes the gRPC connection to the management server.
func (c *clientImpl) Close() {
	if c.done.HasFired() {
		return
	}
	c.done.Fire()
	// TODO: Should we invoke the registered callbacks here with an error that
	// the client is closed?
	c.apiClient.Close()
	c.cc.Close()
	c.logger.Infof("Shutdown")
}

// ResourceType identifies resources in a transport protocol agnostic way. These
// will be used in transport version agnostic code, while the versioned API
// clients will map these to appropriate version URLs.
type ResourceType int

// Version agnostic resource type constants.
const (
	UnknownResource ResourceType = iota
	ListenerResource
	HTTPConnManagerResource
	RouteConfigResource
	ClusterResource
	EndpointsResource
)

func (r ResourceType) String() string {
	switch r {
	case ListenerResource:
		return "ListenerResource"
	case HTTPConnManagerResource:
		return "HTTPConnManagerResource"
	case RouteConfigResource:
		return "RouteConfigResource"
	case ClusterResource:
		return "ClusterResource"
	case EndpointsResource:
		return "EndpointsResource"
	default:
		return "UnknownResource"
	}
}

// IsListenerResource returns true if the provider URL corresponds to an xDS
// Listener resource.
func IsListenerResource(url string) bool {
	return url == version.V2ListenerURL || url == version.V3ListenerURL
}

// IsHTTPConnManagerResource returns true if the provider URL corresponds to an xDS
// HTTPConnManager resource.
func IsHTTPConnManagerResource(url string) bool {
	return url == version.V2HTTPConnManagerURL || url == version.V3HTTPConnManagerURL
}

// IsRouteConfigResource returns true if the provider URL corresponds to an xDS
// RouteConfig resource.
func IsRouteConfigResource(url string) bool {
	return url == version.V2RouteConfigURL || url == version.V3RouteConfigURL
}

// IsClusterResource returns true if the provider URL corresponds to an xDS
// Cluster resource.
func IsClusterResource(url string) bool {
	return url == version.V2ClusterURL || url == version.V3ClusterURL
}

// IsEndpointsResource returns true if the provider URL corresponds to an xDS
// Endpoints resource.
func IsEndpointsResource(url string) bool {
	return url == version.V2EndpointsURL || url == version.V3EndpointsURL
}