@Profile should be able to define profiles to accomplish the 'and' scenario [SPR-15634]

[spring-projects-issues]

Manuel Jordan opened SPR-15634 and commented

The current @Profile's value attribute behaves how an OR

Thus having the following:

@Component
@JmxProfile
@FileProfile
@ManagedResource(description="Admin SimpleFileReaderLoggingWriter")
public class SimpleFileReaderLoggingWriterJmx {

or

@Component
@Profile(value={"jmx","file"})
@ManagedResource(description="Admin SimpleFileReaderLoggingWriter")
public class SimpleFileReaderLoggingWriterJmx {

It behaves: use this bean when the profile is either jmx or file (mostly for the second scenario, seems I need other approach for the first scenario, I mean, an annotation that wraps other annotations)

Seems we need a new attribute that behaves how an AND. It to represents:
use this bean when the profiles are jmx and file

Sadly it is not a @Configuration class where I am able to use the @Profile together with the @Configuration and @Bean to represent the AND scenario. But here we are in the business or model area.

Not sure if exists other approach to accomplish this.

Thank you.

---

Affects: 4.3 GA, 4.3.8

Reference URL: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/38133808/spring-multiple-profiles-active

Issue Links:

• Support AND operator in @Profile annotation [SPR-12458] #17063 Support AND operator in @Profile annotation ("duplicates")

[spring-projects-issues]

Juergen Hoeller commented

Looks like a duplicate of #17063?

[spring-projects-issues]

Manuel Jordan commented

Yes, practically the same scenario. But I think is important that perhaps a new annotation for the non @Configuration classes should be created.