Clean up assertContains() and assertNotContains() #3426
Comments
sebastianbergmann
added
feature-removal
type/backward-compatibility
sebastianbergmann
changed the title
sebastianbergmann
added a commit
that referenced
this issue
Nov 17, 2019
|
@sebastianbergmann the PHPUnit 9 changelog does not document the behavior change of |
|
The ChangeLog has
which links to this ticket where this is explained. |
|
but if you don't click on the link, you don't have any indication that |
nightlinus
added a commit
to nightlinus/rector
that referenced
this issue
Mar 15, 2020
…ity rector As of sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426 assertContains() and assertNotContains() will perform strict comparisons starting with PHPUnit 9 where non-strict comparisons were performed in PHPUnit 8 and earlier; assertContainsEqual() and assertNotContainsEqual() should be used instead if needed non-strict comparison
|
Hey @sebastianbergmann. We got bitten by this change as well in Laravel. I agree with @stof that this should be added to the changelog. If you can point me to where I need to make it I'll be happy to send in a PR. |
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Feb 28, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 3, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 3, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 5, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 5, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 5, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 5, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 6, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 6, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 6, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 6, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 9, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 9, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
stronk7
added a commit
to stronk7/moodle
that referenced
this issue
Mar 11, 2021
The methods assertContains() and assertNotContains() now perform strict (type and value) comparison, pretty much like assertSame() does. A couple of new assertContainsEquals() and assertNotContainsEquals() methods have been created to provide old (non-strict) behavior, pretty much like assertEquals() do. Apart from replacing the calls needing a relaxed comparison to those new methods, there are also a couple of alternative, about how to fix this, depending of every case: - If the test is making any array_values() conversion, then it's better to remove that conversion and use assertArrayHasKey(), that is not strict. - Sometimes if may be also possible to, simply, cast the expectation to the exact type coming in the array. I've not applied this technique to any of the cases in core. Link: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
alexandre-janniaux
added a commit
to alexandre-janniaux/dolibarr
that referenced
this issue
Apr 27, 2023
PHPUnit >= 9 adds assertStringContainsString, which ought to replace assertContains, and PHPUnit >= 9 removed[^1] support for calling assertContains on strings. [^1]: sebastianbergmann/phpunit#3426
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
assertContains()andassertNotContains()onstringhaystacks$ignoreCase,$checkForObjectIdentity, and$checkForNonObjectIdentityofassertContains()andassertNotContains()Assert::contains()TraversableContainsEqualandTraversableContainsIdenticalby inheriting fromTraversableContains(which becomes an abstract base class for these two concrete classes)TraversableContainsIdenticalinAssert::assertContains()andAssert::assertNotContains()(this means thatassertContains()andassertNotContains()will perform strict comparisons starting with PHPUnit 9 where non-strict comparisons were performed in PHPUnit 8 and earlier; useassertContainsEqual()andassertNotContainsEqual()if you need non-strict comparison)The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: