Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Style/ConditionalAssignment auto correct removes nested unless inside else #7290

Closed
DMA57361 opened this issue Aug 15, 2019 · 0 comments
Closed
Assignees
Labels

Comments

@DMA57361
Copy link

DMA57361 commented Aug 15, 2019

We've found some code that the Style/ConditionalAssignment auto-correction ends up breaking by removing a nested unless branch from within the else.

In our case we've changed the nested unless to be another elsif and all is well, but thought I'd report the breaking auto-correct.


Expected / Actual behavior

A nested unless inside an else is removed by the Style/ConditionalAssignment cop, resulting in a change of behaviour.

Steps to reproduce the problem

Given a file called example.rb with this content:

def do_some_work(var)
  if var.any?(:prob_a_check)
    @errors << 'Problem A'
  elsif var.any?(:prob_a_check)
    @errors << 'Problem B'
  else
    unless var.all?(:save)
      @errors << 'Save failed'
    end
  end
end

Run rubocop example.rb --auto-correct --only Style/ConditionalAssignment

$ rubocop example.rb --auto-correct --only Style/ConditionalAssignment
Inspecting 1 file
C

Offenses:

example.rb:2:3: C: [Corrected] Style/ConditionalAssignment: Use the return of the conditional for variable assignment and comparison.
  if var.any?(:prob_a_check) ...
  ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

1 file inspected, 1 offense detected, 1 offense corrected
$

and the example.rb file is left in this state:

def do_some_work(var)
  @errors << if var.any?(:prob_a_check)
    'Problem A'
  elsif var.any?(:prob_b_check)
    'Problem B'
  else
    @errors << 'Save failed'
             end
end

Note that the behaviour of the else branch has changed. The unless has been removed and the @errors << removed from the other branches still remains within the else.

RuboCop version

$ bundle exec rubocop -V
0.74.0 (using Parser 2.6.3.0, running on ruby 2.6.3 x86_64-darwin18)
@jonas054 jonas054 added the bug label Aug 17, 2019
@jonas054 jonas054 self-assigned this Aug 17, 2019
jonas054 added a commit to jonas054/rubocop that referenced this issue Aug 20, 2019
An inner conditional such as

```ruby
  if cond1
    a = 1
  else
    if cond2
      a = 2
    end
  end
```

was not correctly handled. It should not be treated as an `elsif`,
because it is an `else` and there's special logic for `else`
branches.
tas50 added a commit to chef/cookstyle that referenced this issue Oct 30, 2019
This resolves a large number of warnings and gives us a new cop for
automatically migrating the namespace of the cop disables in comments

* [#7407](rubocop/rubocop#7407): Make `Style/FormatStringToken` work inside hashes. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7389](rubocop/rubocop#7389): Fix an issue where passing a formatter might result in an error depending on what character it started with. ([@jfhinchcliffe][])
* [#7397](rubocop/rubocop#7397): Fix extra comments being added to the correction of `Style/SafeNavigation`. ([@rrosenblum][])
* [#7378](rubocop/rubocop#7378): Fix heredoc edge cases in `Layout/EmptyLineAfterGuardClause`. ([@gsamokovarov][])
* [#7404](rubocop/rubocop#7404): Fix a false negative for `Layout/IndentAssignment` when multiple assignment with line breaks on each line. ([@koic][])
* [#7256](rubocop/rubocop#7256): Fix an error of `Style/RedundantParentheses` on method calls where the first argument begins with a hash literal. ([@halfwhole][])
* [#7263](rubocop/rubocop#7263): Make `Layout/SpaceInsideArrayLiteralBrackets` properly handle tab-indented arrays. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7252](rubocop/rubocop#7252): Prevent infinite loops by making `Layout/SpaceInsideStringInterpolation` skip over interpolations that start or end with a line break. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7262](rubocop/rubocop#7262): `Lint/FormatParameterMismatch` did not recognize named format sequences like `%.2<name>f` where the name appears after some modifiers. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7253](rubocop/rubocop#7253): Fix an error for `Lint/NumberConversion` when `#to_i` called without a receiver. ([@koic][])
* [#7271](rubocop/rubocop#7271), [#6498](rubocop/rubocop#6498): Fix an interference between `Style/TrailingCommaIn*Literal` and `Layout/Multiline*BraceLayout` for arrays and hashes. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7241](rubocop/rubocop#7241): Make `Style/FrozenStringLiteralComment` match only true & false. ([@tejasbubane][])
* [#7290](rubocop/rubocop#7290): Handle inner conditional inside `else` in `Style/ConditionalAssignment`. ([@jonas054][])
* [#5788](rubocop/rubocop#5788): Allow block arguments on separate lines if line would be too long in `Layout/MultilineBlockLayout`. ([@jonas054][])
* [#7305](rubocop/rubocop#7305): Register `Style/BlockDelimiters` offense when block result is assigned to an attribute. ([@mvz][])
* [#4802](rubocop/rubocop#4802): Don't leave any `Lint/UnneededCopEnableDirective` offenses undetected/uncorrected. ([@jonas054][])
* [#7326](rubocop/rubocop#7326): Fix a false positive for `Style/AccessModifierDeclarations` when access modifier name is used for hash literal value. ([@koic][])
* [#3591](rubocop/rubocop#3591): Handle modifier `if`/`unless` correctly in `Lint/UselessAssignment`. ([@jonas054][])
* [#7161](rubocop/rubocop#7161): Fix `Style/SafeNavigation` cop for preserve comments inside if expression. ([@tejasbubane][])
* [#5212](rubocop/rubocop#5212): Avoid false positive for braces that are needed to preserve semantics in `Style/BracesAroundHashParameters`. ([@jonas054][])
* [#7353](rubocop/rubocop#7353): Fix a false positive for `Style/RedundantSelf` when receiver and multiple assigned lvalue have the same name. ([@koic][])
* [#7353](rubocop/rubocop#7353): Fix a false positive for `Style/RedundantSelf` when a self receiver is used as a method argument. ([@koic][])
* [#7358](rubocop/rubocop#7358): Fix an incorrect autocorrect for `Style/NestedModifier` when parentheses are required in method arguments. ([@koic][])
* [#7361](rubocop/rubocop#7361): Fix a false positive for `Style/TernaryParentheses` when only the closing parenthesis is used in the last line of condition. ([@koic][])
* [#7369](rubocop/rubocop#7369): Fix an infinite loop error for `Layout/IndentAssignment` with `Layout/IndentFirstArgument` when using multiple assignment. ([@koic][])
* [#7177](rubocop/rubocop#7177), [#7370](rubocop/rubocop#7370): When correcting alignment, do not insert spaces into string literals. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7367](rubocop/rubocop#7367): Fix an error for `Style/OrAssignment` cop when `then` branch body is empty. ([@koic][])
* [#7363](rubocop/rubocop#7363): Fix an incorrect autocorrect for `Layout/SpaceInsideBlockBraces` and `Style/BlockDelimiters` when using multiline empty braces. ([@koic][])
* [#7212](rubocop/rubocop#7212): Fix a false positive for `Layout/EmptyLinesAroundAccessModifier` and `UselessAccessModifier` when using method with the same name as access modifier around a method definition. ([@koic][])
* [#7217](rubocop/rubocop#7217): Make `Style/TrailingMethodEndStatement` work on more than the first `def`. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7190](rubocop/rubocop#7190): Support lower case drive letters on Windows. ([@jonas054][])
* Fix the auto-correction of `Lint/UnneededSplatExpansion` when the splat expansion of `Array.new` with a block is assigned to a variable. ([@rrosenblum][])
* [#5628](rubocop/rubocop#5628): Fix an error of `Layout/SpaceInsideStringInterpolation` on interpolations with multiple statements. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7128](rubocop/rubocop#7128): Make `Metrics/LineLength` aware of shebang. ([@koic][])
* [#6861](rubocop/rubocop#6861): Fix a false positive for `Layout/IndentationWidth` when using `EnforcedStyle: outdent` of `Layout/AccessModifierIndentation`. ([@koic][])
* [#7235](rubocop/rubocop#7235): Fix an error where `Style/ConditionalAssignment` would swallow a nested `if` condition. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7242](rubocop/rubocop#7242): Make `Style/ConstantVisibility` work on non-trivial class and module bodies. ([@buehmann][])
* [#5265](rubocop/rubocop#5265): Improved `Layout/ExtraSpacing` cop to handle nested consecutive assignments. ([@jfelchner][])
* [#7215](rubocop/rubocop#7215): Make it clear what's wrong in the message from `Style/GuardClause`. ([@jonas054][])
* [#7245](rubocop/rubocop#7245): Make cops detect string interpolations in more contexts: inside of backticks, regular expressions, and symbols. ([@buehmann][])
 [#7275](rubocop/rubocop#7275): Make `Style/VariableName` aware argument names when invoking a method. ([@koic][])
* [#3534](rubocop/rubocop#3534): Make `Style/IfUnlessModifier` report and auto-correct modifier lines that are too long. ([@jonas054][])
* [#7261](rubocop/rubocop#7261): `Style/FrozenStringLiteralComment` no longer inserts an empty line after the comment. This is left to `Layout/EmptyLineAfterMagicComment`. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7091](rubocop/rubocop#7091): `Style/FormatStringToken` now detects format sequences with flags and modifiers. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7319](rubocop/rubocop#7319): Rename `IgnoredMethodPatterns` option to `IgnoredPatterns` option for `Style/MethodCallWithArgsParentheses`. ([@koic][])
* [#7345](rubocop/rubocop#7345): Mark unsafe for `Style/YodaCondition`. ([@koic][])
* [#7170](rubocop/rubocop#7170): Fix a false positive for `Layout/RescueEnsureAlignment` when def line is preceded with `private_class_method`. ([@tatsuyafw][])
* [#7186](rubocop/rubocop#7186): Fix a false positive for `Style/MixinUsage` when using inside multiline block and `if` condition is after `include`. ([@koic][])
* [#7099](rubocop/rubocop#7099): Fix an error of `Layout/RescueEnsureAlignment` on assigned blocks. ([@tatsuyafw][])
* [#5088](rubocop/rubocop#5088): Fix an error of `Layout/MultilineMethodCallIndentation` on method chains inside an argument. ([@buehmann][])
* [#4719](rubocop/rubocop#4719): Make `Layout/Tab` detect tabs between string literals. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7203](rubocop/rubocop#7203): Fix an infinite loop error for `Layout/SpaceInsideBlockBraces` when `EnforcedStyle: no_space` with `SpaceBeforeBlockParameters: false` are set in multiline block. ([@koic][])
* [#6653](rubocop/rubocop#6653): Fix a bug where `Layout/IndentHeredoc` would remove empty lines when autocorrecting heredocs. ([@buehmann][])
* [#7188](rubocop/rubocop#7188): Include inspected file location in auto-correction error. ([@pocke][])

Signed-off-by: Tim Smith <tsmith@chef.io>
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants