Permissions decorator running after pydantic validation

[simonjharris]

I'm looking into migrating from flask-pydantic to flask-openapi3, but one problem I'm having is around the authentication decorators we currently use. When using flask-openapi3 pydantic validation is taking place before the auth checks.

So when making an unauthenticated request I receive a 422 Unprocessable Entity response rather than 401 Unauthorized. If the request body is valid, the 401 response is returned, but an invalid request body yields a 422.

Is this expected behaviour?

example:

@user_admin_api.post(
    "/admin/users",
    summary="Create a user",
    responses={HTTPStatus.CREATED: UserIdResponse},
    tags=[user_admin_tag]
)
@permission_only("perm.users.create")
def create_user(body: UserCreationWrapper, user_id: str, **_):
    ...

Environment:

• Python version: 3.9
• Operating system: mac
• Flask version: 2.0.3
• flask-openapi3 version: 3.0.0rc1

[luolingchun]

Can you write a detailed example?
Here's a decorator sample code for permission validation:

https://github.com/luolingchun/flask-api-demo/blob/master/src/app/api/user.py#L54

https://github.com/luolingchun/flask-api-demo/blob/master/src/app/api/admin.py#L31

https://github.com/luolingchun/flask-api-demo/blob/master/src/app/utils/jwt_tools.py#L52

By the way, user_id: str, **_ is a misuse of the attempt to support only a few parameters: path, query, form, body, header, cookie

Here is the help documentation: https://luolingchun.github.io/flask-openapi3/v2.x/Usage/Request/

[simonjharris]

Here's a unit test MWE:

(This setup works with flask-pydantic)

import pytest
from pydantic import BaseModel

from flask_openapi3 import OpenAPI
from functools import wraps

app = OpenAPI(__name__)


class ForbiddenError(Exception):
    pass


class TestModel(BaseModel):
    field: str


@app.errorhandler(ForbiddenError)
def handle_forbidden_error(e):
    return "Forbidden", 403


@pytest.fixture
def client():
    client = app.test_client()

    yield client


def intercept():
    def middle(f):
        @wraps(f)
        def wrapper(*args, **kwargs):
            raise ForbiddenError()

        return wrapper

    return middle


@app.post("/forbidden")
@intercept()
def forbidden_route(body: TestModel):
    return "success", 200


def test_forbidden_error(client):
    r = client.post("/forbidden")
    assert r.status_code == 403
    assert r.text == "Forbidden"

test_interception_decorator.py::test_forbidden_error FAILED              [100%]
test_interception_decorator.py:49 (test_forbidden_error)
422 != 403

Expected :403
Actual   :422
<Click to see difference>

client = <FlaskClient <OpenAPI 'test_interception_decorator'>>

    def test_forbidden_error(client):
        r = client.post("/forbidden")
>       assert r.status_code == 403
E       assert 422 == 403
E        +  where 422 = <WrapperTestResponse streamed [422 UNPROCESSABLE ENTITY]>.status_code

test_interception_decorator.py:52: AssertionError

[luolingchun]

I compared flask-openapi3 and flask-pydantic and came to the following conclusion:

1. flask-pydantic uses a standalone @validate() decorator, so you can choose the @intercept() execution order.

   # Execute @validate() first and then @intercept(), 
   # which will throw a validation error, just like flask-openapi3 here.
   @app.route("/", methods=["GET"])
   @validate()
   @intercept()
   def get(query: QueryModel):
       ...
   
   
   # Execute @intercept() first and then @validate(), @intercept() throws an exception.
   @app.route("/", methods=["GET"])
   @intercept()
   @validate()
   def get(query: QueryModel):
       ...

2. flask-openapi3 does not have a @validate() decorator, so it must pass parameter validation before continuing execution.

[simonjharris]

Thanks for your reply, I see your point here.

I did a bit more testing and noticed that if I remove the @wraps() within intercept, the test passes. I'm not sure if this expected behaviour.