Semantic commands are missing in shortcut editor

[krassowski]

Description

Semantic commands (#11386, e.g. "Restart and run all cells", runmenu:restart-and-run-all) are missing in Setting Editor's Shortcuts section:

This might be related to #11898.

Reproduce

Expected behavior

1. Shortcuts are searched by all: label, caption and command ID
2. Semantic commands have proper labels and captions

Context

• JupyterLab version: 3.x and 4.0.0alpha

[fcollonval]

Do you see the bug in 3.x too? If so, the bug may not be related to Semantic command as that feature was not backported (due to the induced api change).

[krassowski]

I see it on both 3.5 and master. Maybe was introduced by #10469? But then I don't know why it is also seen on 4.0.

[JasonWeill]

I can also repro with master

[fcollonval]

Looking into this, actually this concerns all commands that do not have an existing shortcuts. The shortcut editors does not get the list of commands but the shortcuts settings.

Fun fact the list of all commands is built to set the description of the JSON schema that is displayed in the JSON Settings editor.

[fcollonval]

Adding the list of commands without shortcuts is easy. But the trouble is that they don't have selectors. So the UI must be extended to allow for a selector to be defined; may be we could define a default selector (function of the command category (?)).

[krassowski]

Looking into this, actually this concerns all commands that do not have an existing shortcuts

Thanks for looking into it futher!

may be we could define a default selector (function of the command category (?)

or just go with "body" and advise users to change it as needed?