arch-io.adoc

Jetty I/O Architecture

Jetty libraries (both client and server) use Java NIO to handle I/O, so that at its core Jetty I/O is completely non-blocking.

Jetty I/O: SelectorManager

The core class of Jetty I/O is SelectorManager.

SelectorManager manages internally a configurable number of ManagedSelectors. Each ManagedSelector wraps an instance of java.nio.channels.Selector that in turn manages a number of java.nio.channels.SocketChannel instances.

Note	TODO: add image

SocketChannel instances can be created by clients when connecting to a server and by a server when accepting connections from clients. In both cases the SocketChannel instance is passed to SelectorManager (which passes it to ManagedSelector and eventually to java.nio.channels.Selector) to be registered for use within Jetty.

It is possible for an application to create the SocketChannel instances outside Jetty, even perform some initial network traffic also outside Jetty (for example for authentication purposes), and then pass the SocketChannel instance to SelectorManager for use within Jetty.

This example shows how a client can connect to a server:

link:{doc_code}/org/eclipse/jetty/docs/programming/SelectorManagerDocs.java[role=include]

This example shows how a server accepts a client connection:

link:{doc_code}/org/eclipse/jetty/docs/programming/SelectorManagerDocs.java[role=include]

Jetty I/O: EndPoint and Connection

SocketChannels that are passed to SelectorManager are wrapped into two related components: an EndPoint and a Connection.

EndPoint is the Jetty abstraction for a SocketChannel: you can read bytes from an EndPoint via EndPoint.fill(ByteBuffer), you can write bytes to an EndPoint via EndPoint.flush(ByteBuffer...) and EndPoint.write(Callback, ByteBuffer...), you can close an EndPoint via EndPoint.close(), etc.

Connection is the Jetty abstraction that is responsible to read bytes from the EndPoint and to deserialize the read bytes into objects. For example, an HTTP/1.1 server-side Connection implementation is responsible to deserialize HTTP/1.1 request bytes into an HTTP request object. Conversely, an HTTP/1.1 client-side Connection implementation is responsible to deserialize HTTP/1.1 response bytes into an HTTP response object.

Connection is the abstraction that implements the reading side of a specific protocol such as HTTP/1.1, or HTTP/2, or WebSocket: it is able to read incoming communication in that protocol.

The writing side for a specific protocol may be implemented in the Connection but may also be implemented in other components, although eventually the bytes to be written will be written through the EndPoint.

While there is primarily just one implementation of EndPoint,SocketChannelEndPoint (used both on the client-side and on the server-side), there are many implementations of Connection, typically two for each protocol (one for the client-side and one for the server-side).

The EndPoint and Connection pairs can be chained, for example in case of encrypted communication using the TLS protocol. There is an EndPoint and Connection TLS pair where the EndPoint reads the encrypted bytes from the socket and the Connection decrypts them; next in the chain there is an EndPoint and Connection pair where the EndPoint "reads" decrypted bytes (provided by the previous Connection) and the Connection deserializes them into specific protocol objects (for example HTTP/2 frame objects).

Certain protocols, such as WebSocket, start the communication with the server using one protocol (for example, HTTP/1.1), but then change the communication to use another protocol (for example, WebSocket). EndPoint supports changing the Connection object on-the-fly via EndPoint.upgrade(Connection). This allows to use the HTTP/1.1 Connection during the initial communication and later to replace it with a WebSocket Connection.

Note	TODO: add a section on UpgradeFrom and UpgradeTo?

SelectorManager is an abstract class because while it knows how to create concrete EndPoint instances, it does not know how to create protocol specific Connection instances.

Creating Connection instances is performed on the server-side by ConnectionFactorys and on the client-side by ClientConnectionFactorys

On the server-side, the component that aggregates a SelectorManager with a set of ConnectionFactorys is ServerConnectors for TCP/IP sockets, and UnixDomainServerConnector for Unix-Domain sockets (see the server-side architecture section for more information).

On the client-side, the components that aggregates a SelectorManager with a set of ClientConnectionFactorys are HttpClientTransport subclasses (see the client-side architecture section for more information).

Jetty I/O: EndPoint

The Jetty I/O library use Java NIO to handle I/O, so that I/O is non-blocking.

At the Java NIO level, in order to be notified when a SocketChannel has data to be read, the SelectionKey.OP_READ flag must be set.

In the Jetty I/O library, you can call EndPoint.fillInterested(Callback) to declare interest in the "read" (also called "fill") event, and the Callback parameter is the object that is notified when such an event occurs.

At the Java NIO level, a SocketChannel is always writable, unless it becomes TCP congested. In order to be notified when a SocketChannel uncongests and it is therefore writable again, the SelectionKey.OP_WRITE flag must be set.

In the Jetty I/O library, you can call EndPoint.write(Callback, ByteBuffer…​) to write the ByteBuffers and the Callback parameter is the object that is notified when the whole write is finished (i.e. all ByteBuffers have been fully written, even if they are delayed by TCP congestion/uncongestion).

The EndPoint APIs abstract out the Java NIO details by providing non-blocking APIs based on Callback objects for I/O operations. The EndPoint APIs are typically called by Connection implementations, see this section.

Jetty I/O: Connection

Connection is the abstraction that deserializes incoming bytes into objects, for example an HTTP request object or a WebSocket frame object, that can be used by more abstract layers.

Connection instances have two lifecycle methods:

• Connection.onOpen(), invoked when the Connection is associated with the EndPoint

• Connection.onClose(Throwable), invoked when the Connection is disassociated from the EndPoint, where the Throwable parameter indicates whether the disassociation was normal (when the parameter is null) or was due to an error (when the parameter is not null)

When a Connection is first created, it is not registered for any Java NIO event. It is therefore typical to implement onOpen() to call EndPoint.fillInterested(Callback) so that the Connection declares interest for read events and it is invoked (via the Callback) when the read event happens.

Abstract class AbstractConnection partially implements Connection and provides simpler APIs. The example below shows a typical implementation that extends AbstractConnection:

link:{doc_code}/org/eclipse/jetty/docs/programming/SelectorManagerDocs.java[role=include]

Jetty I/O: Connection.Listener

TODO

Jetty I/O: Network Echo

With the concepts above it is now possible to write a simple, fully non-blocking, Connection implementation that simply echoes the bytes that it reads back to the other peer.

A naive, but wrong, implementation may be the following:

link:{doc_code}/org/eclipse/jetty/docs/programming/SelectorManagerDocs.java[role=include]

Warning

The implementation above is wrong and leads to StackOverflowError.

The problem with this implementation is that if the writes always complete synchronously (i.e. without being delayed by TCP congestion), you end up with this sequence of calls:

Connection.onFillable()
  EndPoint.write()
    Connection.succeeded()
      Connection.onFillable()
        EndPoint.write()
          Connection.succeeded()
          ...

which leads to StackOverflowError.

This is a typical side effect of asynchronous programming using non-blocking APIs, and happens in the Jetty I/O library as well.

Note	The callback is invoked synchronously for efficiency reasons. Submitting the invocation of the callback to an Executor to be invoked in a different thread would cause a context switch and make simple writes extremely inefficient.

This side effect of asynchronous programming leading to StackOverflowError is so common that the Jetty libraries have a generic solution for it: a specialized Callback implementation named org.eclipse.jetty.util.IteratingCallback that turns recursion into iteration, therefore avoiding the StackOverflowError.

IteratingCallback is a Callback implementation that should be passed to non-blocking APIs such as EndPoint.write(Callback, ByteBuffer…​) when they are performed in a loop.

IteratingCallback works by starting the loop with IteratingCallback.iterate(). In turn, this calls IteratingCallback.process(), an abstract method that must be implemented with the code that should be executed for each loop.

Method process() must return:

• Action.SCHEDULED, to indicate whether the loop has performed a non-blocking, possibly asynchronous, operation

• Action.IDLE, to indicate that the loop should temporarily be suspended to be resumed later

• Action.SUCCEEDED to indicate that the loop exited successfully

Any exception thrown within process() exits the loops with a failure.

Now that you know how IteratingCallback works, a correct implementation for the echo Connection is the following:

link:{doc_code}/org/eclipse/jetty/docs/programming/SelectorManagerDocs.java[role=include]

When onFillable() is called, for example the first time that bytes are available from the network, the iteration is started. Starting the iteration calls process(), where a buffer is allocated and filled with bytes read from the network via EndPoint.fill(ByteBuffer); the buffer is subsequently written back via EndPoint.write(Callback, ByteBuffer…​) — note that the callback passed to EndPoint.write() is this, i.e. the IteratingCallback itself; finally Action.SCHEDULED is returned, returning from the process() method.

At this point, the call to EndPoint.write(Callback, ByteBuffer…​) may have completed synchronously; IteratingCallback would know that and call process() again; within process(), the buffer has already been allocated so it will be reused, saving further allocations; the buffer will be filled and possibly written again; Action.SCHEDULED is returned again, returning again from the process() method.

At this point, the call to EndPoint.write(Callback, ByteBuffer…​) may have not completed synchronously, so IteratingCallback will not call process() again; the processing thread is free to return to the Jetty I/O system where it may be put back into the thread pool. If this was the only active network connection, the system would now be idle, with no threads blocked, waiting that the write() completes. This thread-less wait is one of the most important features that make non-blocking asynchronous servers more scalable: they use less resources.

Eventually, the Jetty I/O system will notify that the write() completed; this notifies the IteratingCallback that can now resume the loop and call process() again.

When process() is called, it is possible that zero bytes are read from the network; in this case, you want to deallocate the buffer since the other peer may never send more bytes for the Connection to read, or it may send them after a long pause — in both cases we do not want to retain the memory allocated by the buffer; next, you want to call fillInterested() to declare again interest for read events, and return Action.IDLE since there is nothing to write back and therefore the loop may be suspended. When more bytes are again available to be read from the network, onFillable() will be called again and that will start the iteration again.

Another possibility is that during process() the read returns -1 indicating that the other peer has closed the connection; this means that there will not be more bytes to read and the loop can be exited, so you return Action.SUCCEEDED; IteratingCallback will then call onCompleteSuccess() where you can close the EndPoint.

The last case is that during process() an exception is thrown, for example by EndPoint.fill(ByteBuffer) or, in more advanced implementations, by code that parses the bytes that have been read and finds them unacceptable; any exception thrown within process() will be caught by IteratingCallback that will exit the loop with a failure and call onCompleteFailure(Throwable) with the exception that has been thrown, where you can close the EndPoint, passing the exception that is the reason for closing prematurely the EndPoint.

Important

Asynchronous programming is hard. Rely on the Jetty classes to implement Connection to avoid mistakes that will be difficult to diagnose and reproduce.