Issues with multiple build artifacts and packaging into archives

[safaci2000]

I'm trying to release an application that contains multiple binaries/entrypoints. This seems to work for almost everything except Archives and homebrews that's giving me some issues. What am I doing wrong here?

Every artifact is supposed to have two binaries, gdg and gdg-generate.

Here's the output of homebrew which reflects what is in the archives as well.

Basically,

gdg is in: gdg_Darwin_all.tar.gz
gdg-generate is in: gdg_Darwin_arm64.tar.gz, gdg_Darwin_x86_64.tar.gz
contains both: gdg_Linux_arm64.tar.gz, gdg_Linux_x86_64.tar.gz

Every package should contain all builds, so what am I missing? What behavior is making some tar.gz contain one or both. It seems like it's specific to OSX Darwin build while the Linux and windows artifacts seems to work fine (Windows not listed above but that packages up correctly)

Forumula.rb

# typed: false
# frozen_string_literal: true

# This file was generated by GoReleaser. DO NOT EDIT.
class Gdg < Formula
  desc "Grafana Dash-n-Grab (GDG) -- Dashboard/DataSource Manager for grafana supporting backup/restore to local filesystem, s3, gcs, azure, and other S3 compatible storage engines."
  homepage "https://software.es.net/gdg"
  version "0.5.2-rc1"

  on_macos do
    if Hardware::CPU.arm?
      url "https://github.com/esnet/gdg/releases/download/v0.5.2-rc1/gdg_Darwin_arm64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "3e1687d0f4bbf4b80b762839400b368864fad4e815cb9be52322114547e84bc4"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
    if Hardware::CPU.intel?
      url "https://github.com/esnet/gdg/releases/download/v0.5.2-rc1/gdg_Darwin_x86_64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "7ea56a295b4a41fc10529b43b1750a745bf283f513c3cecb4a48d52aa82fa9f7"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
    url "https://github.com/esnet/gdg/releases/download/v0.5.2-rc1/gdg_Darwin_all.tar.gz"
    sha256 "4971196448428bcb5f255be6b9ddd862161fb6142886fd4521dda2aff1f03fff"

    def install
      bin.install "gdg"
    end
  end

  on_linux do
    if Hardware::CPU.arm? && Hardware::CPU.is_64_bit?
      url "https://github.com/esnet/gdg/releases/download/v0.5.2-rc1/gdg_Linux_arm64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "115735fdcd4f461e069b808993cc97942c0b15f545a76acfcec2b681f5d24dce"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg"
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
    if Hardware::CPU.intel?
      url "https://github.com/esnet/gdg/releases/download/v0.5.2-rc1/gdg_Linux_x86_64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "b7921b984860f92ecccdecd3cd5691aa61570758caf99d57c1e87898159326c4"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg"
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
  end
end

.goreleaser.yaml

before:
  hooks:
    - go mod tidy
    - go generate ./...

source:
  rlcp: true

builds:
  - id: gdg
    env:
      - CGO_ENABLED=0
    binary: gdg
    ldflags: -s -w -X github.com/esnet/gdg/internal/version.GitCommit={{ .Commit }} -X github.com/esnet/gdg/internal/version.BuildDate={{ .Date }}  -X github.com/esnet/gdg/internal/version.Version={{ .Tag }}
    main: ./cmd/gdg
    goos:
      - linux
      - windows
      - darwin
    goarch:
      - arm64
      - 386
      - amd64
  - id: gdg-generate
    env:
      - CGO_ENABLED=0
    binary: gdg-generate
    ldflags: -s -w -X github.com/esnet/gdg/internal/version.GitCommit={{ .Commit }} -X github.com/esnet/gdg/internal/version.BuildDate={{ .Date }}  -X github.com/esnet/gdg/internal/version.Version={{ .Tag }}
    main: ./cmd/gen
    goos:
      - linux
      - windows
      - darwin
    goarch:
      - arm64
      - 386
      - amd64


universal_binaries:
  - replace: true

release:
  prerelease: auto


brews:
  - name: gdg
    homepage: https://software.es.net/gdg
    commit_msg_template: "Brew formula update for {{ .ProjectName }} version {{ .Tag }}"
    description: Grafana Dash-n-Grab (GDG) -- Dashboard/DataSource Manager for grafana supporting backup/restore to local filesystem, s3, gcs, azure, and other S3 compatible storage engines.
    folder: Formula
    repository:
      owner: esnet
      name: homebrew-gdg
      token: "{{ .Env.HOMEBREW_TOKEN }}"
      branch: main
    commit_author:
      name: GDG ESNet
      email: gdg@es.net

archives:
  - name_template: >-
      {{ .ProjectName }}_
      {{- title .Os }}_
      {{- if eq .Arch "amd64" }}x86_64
      {{- else if eq .Arch "386" }}i386
      {{- else }}{{ .Arch }}{{ end }}
    allow_different_binary_count: true
    format_overrides:
      - goos: windows
        format: zip
    builds:
      - gdg
      - gdg-generate
    files:
      - README*
      - config/importer-example.yml
      - config/templates-example.yml

checksum:
  name_template: "checksums.txt"
snapshot:
  name_template: "{{ .Tag }}-next"
changelog:
  sort: asc
  filters:
    exclude:
      - "^docs:"
      - "^test:"

[caarlos0]

I tried your config here, and it seems to have worked properly:

# typed: false
# frozen_string_literal: true

# This file was generated by GoReleaser. DO NOT EDIT.
class Gdg < Formula
  desc "Grafana Dash-n-Grab (GDG) -- Dashboard/DataSource Manager for grafana supporting backup/restore to local filesystem, s3, gcs, azure, and other S3 compatible storage engines."
  homepage "https://software.es.net/gdg"
  version "v0.0.0-next"

  on_macos do
    if Hardware::CPU.intel?
      url "https://github.com///releases/download/v0.0.0/foo_Darwin_x86_64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "f5c1c9991a73361e0131af12e94dc22a11cb1741fcd0ab53f28ae5f97bdd4636"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg"
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
    if Hardware::CPU.arm?
      url "https://github.com///releases/download/v0.0.0/foo_Darwin_arm64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "9f476de26f9323adf1ca515fd40b1d2abe9e2d70e6a9501ad9b56878ed5c5994"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg"
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
  end

  on_linux do
    if Hardware::CPU.intel?
      url "https://github.com///releases/download/v0.0.0/foo_Linux_x86_64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "4369f5afb293a464a93996f60c8f9098403ca64d5c3049b0fecfe7e30d5092e8"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg"
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
    if Hardware::CPU.arm? && Hardware::CPU.is_64_bit?
      url "https://github.com///releases/download/v0.0.0/foo_Linux_arm64.tar.gz"
      sha256 "ea7d87f00f00f1797c757c34a2ac97a6d9d754d3f8e2f6e71c4cd081f1d02781"

      def install
        bin.install "gdg"
        bin.install "gdg-generate"
      end
    end
  end
end

which version of goreleaser are you using?

[safaci2000]

One final question and I don't really see any reason why I'm seeing this behavior, but if I use:

     ids:
       - gdg
       - gdg-generate

it doesn't seem to work while the code you linked or the one below does. Any reason I would be seeing this behavior?

    ids: [ gdg gdg-generate ]

I'm also seeing a warning about:

• pipe skipped reason=no darwin binaries found with id "gdg"

Is this some yaml bug i'm seeing? I'm not sure why the code would differentiate between the two array representations.

I'm especially asking since the docs reference the former rather than the latter in the example code.

[caarlos0]

might be, have you tried quoting them?

[safaci2000]

That didn't change anything. I'm not sure why it's exhibiting this behavior. I guess an FYI. It's not a blocker for me but a it odd.

Also, thank you so much for your assistance @caarlos0 it's really appreciated.

[caarlos0]

ah, I actually gave you bad feedback it seems

it should be:

universal_binaries:
  - id: gdg
    name_template: gdg
    replace: true
    ids: [gdg]
  - id: gdg-generate
    name_template: gdg-generate
    replace: true
    ids: [gdg-generate]

you need to create one universal binary for each binary you are building... the ids: [foo bar] thing "worked" because it actually matched nothing, as foo bar was treated as a single item (it should have beend [foo, bar].

Anyway, the snipped above will fix all your problems :D

[safaci2000]

There we go, that works! I wonder why it worked, does the fallback on a mismatch to include all? I can't seem to do it, but you mark the answer above as the "Answer' to the question. It seems pointing others the other post would be invalid.