TODO.md

This will serve as a high level overview of future changes either in progress or planned. The Issues list is for specific bugs or feature requests.

Python

• PEP8 compliance.
• Details which may or may not be included in PEP8 might be, consistent variable naming conventions, and use of single/double quotes.
• Porting to Python 3. This is done in that we are now Py2 and Py3 compatible as of 0.5.0; but we may deprecate Py2 soon Python2 is now deprecated, as is Python3 below 3.6.

A note on the above - took a look at it last December, but had problems in particular with some twisted elements, specifically txsocksx Done as of 0.4.2, now switched to txtorcon.

• Twisted related: there are cases where much better use of deferreds should be possible.

Testing

• Find a correct model for tests using twisted; current arch. used in test_client_protocol.py (and daemon) is extremely ugly, involving hardcoded timeouts. It uses twisted.trial which I believe(?) is the correct module to use, but I don't seem to have figured out the right/best way to use it.
• Need end to end testing of user functions, especially on Qt. Currently this is done manually which is not practical.
• Current test/ygrunner.py is a nice way to do "by-hand" testing of various clients against either honest or malicious counterparties (makers). Can and should be extended to be automatic, with taker running in same process.
• Issues of running bots in parallel in tests: sourcing the configuration, and sharing of global files like commitmentlist.

Architecture

* Probably move all user data to ~ ; see comment.

This was done as of v0.6.2

• Make use of the schedule design to fold together sendpayment and tumbler (they share a lot of cli options anyway).
• Investigate what refactoring of the daemon protocol is necessary so it is possible to run protocol instances concurrently.
• Moving elements shared into joinmarketbase - in particular, an object representing offers like JMOffer, which could have serialization routines for passing between client and daemon.
• Do more work on TLS connection so that it becomes possible to run the daemon locally without any privacy concern (there is already no bitcoin security concern even without it).

Blockchain

• We should look into lite-client modes, in particular client-side filtering as used by Neutrino and others, and described [here](https://github.com/Roasbeef/bips/blob/master/gcs_light_client.mediawiki}.

• Re-work the existing electrum code so it works reliably and with some decent performance (easier short term goal). This was previously marked 'done' but is now very much "un-done" since the code has not been updated and doesn't work; it's debatable what should be done, if anything, about it. It's certainly useful to have Electrum for testing/testnet.

Joinmarket protocol

• The issue693 problem is by far the most important one to spend time on.

The fidelity bond code introduced in #544 can serve as a basis for removing this issue, but it will most sensibly fold into a broader protocol upgrade.

Done as of v0.9.5. Makers now use fidelity bonds.

* bech32 addresses for joins; possibly mixed address types, needs discussion.

Bech32 native segwit has become default for coinjoins as of 0.8.0.

• change format of data transfer (in particular, avoid double encoding which wastes space)

An additional possibility is discussesd in #415 namely, possible decentralized architecture for Joinmarket inter-participant communication.

This is done as of v0.9.6, we now have redundant directory nodes and peer to peer transaction negotiation over Tor, albeit it will doubtless require considerable refinement over time.

Qt GUI

* Binary build process automated and, more importantly, working for Linux, Windows and Mac.

There is no current process for building binaries on Mac or Windows (theoretically the latter is possible but a mess, so I'm not doing it).

Windows binaries are now being built in an automated way via #641. The same process for Mac does not yet exist, however (though it is probably fairly feasible).

• Qt5 support, as Qt4 is being deprecated (see issue204). Done as of 0.5.0.

Alternative implementations

• Build an alternative client implementation in Java or Javascript for example, using some existing Bitcoin library in that language, perhaps using some lite client solution e.g. SPV, and then connecting to the daemon (executable or Python script).

This can now be considered 'done' as per the full RPC spec at https://joinmarket-org.github.io/joinmarket-clientserver/api/ based on the daemon scripts/jmwalletd.py which now offers almost all of the functionality of Joinmarket, and the JAM client at https://github.com/joinmarket-webui/joinmarket-webui

Bitcoin

We use coincurve as a binding to libsecp256k1. The current jmbitcoin package morphed over many iterations from the original pybitcointools base code. We need to rework it considerably as it is very messy architecturally, particularly in regard to data types. A full rewrite is likely the best option, including in particular the removal of data type flexibility; use binary only within the package (which will also require rewrite and simplification of some parts of the wallet code).

A rewrite of the transaction signing portion of the jmbitcoin code will need to account for the future probable need to support taproot and Schnorr (without yet implementing it).

This was all done in the switch to python-bitcointx included in 0.7.0 via #536 . Complete removal of coincurve for all functions is still to be done. Now done via #1134

Taproot support needs to be added, see #1084.

Sending to taproot addresses was included as of v0.9.5.

Extra features.

PayJoin is already implemented, though not in GUI, that could be added. Full BIP78 Payjoin now in GUI also.

Maker functionality is not in GUI, that could quite plausibly be added and is quite widely requested. - See #487, this is now largely functional but still needs work. However this is probably superseded by work on the RPC-API, see above under "Alternative implementations".

SNICKER exists currently as a proposed code update but is not quite ready, see #403. "Full" SNICKER functionality is now merged via #768, albeit it will need more testing before it can be auto-switched on for mainnet yieldgenerators.

Hardware wallet support is a tough one, but there is some interesting discussion around possibilities, see #663.